Earlier this week, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) proposed what it describes as the first and most comprehensive set of regulatory reforms to the permanent labor certification program (PERM) since it took effect in 2005. The proposal would reshape nearly every part of the PERM process, including how and how long employers recruit, which occupations are covered, how layoffs affect eligibility, and what employers must submit and post. Though not yet law, it warrants sponsoring employers' attention now.
PERM is the first step in most employer-sponsored green card cases. It is fundamentally a labor market test: The employer must demonstrate that there are no minimally qualified U.S. workers who are willing and available to fill the position.
At a glance: Key proposed changes
| Area |
Current rule |
Proposed rule |
| How jobs are advertised |
A state job posting, two Sunday newspaper ads and, for professional jobs, a few extra recruiting steps. |
No more newspaper ads; advertising moves online and must be at least as broad as the employer's usual hiring. |
| How long jobs are advertised |
About 30 days. |
At least 90 days, and the employer must show a genuine effort to hire U.S. workers. |
| Proof of recruitment |
Kept on file and shown to DOL only if requested. |
Sent to DOL with every application. |
| Nurses and physical therapists (Schedule A) |
Skip the recruitment step entirely, as do certain workers of exceptional ability. |
Exemption ends; these jobs must go through full recruitment. |
| Layoffs |
Recent layoffs in the same job must be taken into account before filing. |
Layoffs in similar jobs within the past two years can block filing, with new reporting and notice obligations. |
| Workplace notice |
Posted for 10 business days. |
Must stay posted until the green card petition (Form I-140) is approved. |
| Remote jobs |
Not specifically addressed. |
Worker's home location must be identified; DOL is asking whether fully remote jobs should qualify at all. |
A shift away from legacy media for recruitment
The current PERM recruitment rules still require Sunday newspaper print advertisements, a method that bears little resemblance to how employers actually find workers today. Few qualified candidates for professional positions look for jobs in the Sunday paper, and employers have for years paid for print ads that serve mainly as a compliance exercise.
The proposal would replace print advertising with online recruitment through employer websites, commercial job boards, social media, job fairs, and campus recruitment. The proposal would, however, require PERM recruitment to be at least as extensive as the employer's normal recruitment for comparable positions that do not involve PERM. Employers that use many recruiting channels will therefore have more required steps, and every employer will need a clear, documented picture of how it ordinarily recruits for each occupation it sponsors.
Eliminating Schedule A is difficult to justify
Schedule A currently lets employers skip the labor market test for professional nurses, physical therapists, and individuals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts, and, instead, file for permanent residence directly with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS). The proposal would end that exemption and require full PERM recruitment for these occupations.
In our view, this change is hard to justify. These occupations are on Schedule A because the government has already determined that there are shortages in the U.S. labor market. Requiring employers to prove an acknowledged shortage adds cost and delay without benefiting U.S. workers and will likely prolong staffing gaps at hospitals, health systems, long-term care providers, and other employers that rely on foreign-trained nurses and physical therapists.
Implications for employers regarding recruitment length and 'good-faith efforts'
Two features of the proposal could create significant practical problems for employers. The first is the requirement to advertise positions for at least 90 calendar days, roughly three times today's typical period, along with tighter timing rules between recruitment and filing. This would add months to every green card case, a delay that matters most for H-1B employees nearing the six-year limit who depend on a timely PERM filing to extend their status, and for employers trying to retain key talent in a competitive market.
The second is the requirement to demonstrate "good-faith efforts" to recruit qualified U.S. workers, a standard that DOL's announcement does not clearly define. Without clear criteria, employers cannot know in advance whether their recruitment will be judged sufficient, and outcomes may vary by analyst. Combined with the new requirement to submit recruitment materials with the application, this subjective standard is likely to lead to more denials, audits, and appeals, and we expect it to be a central subject of public comments.
Other significant changes
The layoff provisions are especially relevant to employers that have recently reduced headcount or plan to. The proposal would bar certain employers that laid off U.S. workers within the past two years from seeking PERM certification for the same or similar positions, and would require them to consider laid-off workers through both the labor certification and I-140 stages.
Depending on the circumstances, an employer may need to report a qualifying layoff to DOL within five business days and notify USCIS (if an I-140 is pending) and affected workers. Because the proposal also reaches layoffs of workers placed by third-party staffing companies, a reduction in force could directly affect PERM eligibility.
The proposal would also keep the notice of filing posted through I-140 approval, require more recruitment documentation up front, codify DOL's electronic filing practices, and address fully remote positions, with DOL seeking comment on whether they should remain PERM-eligible and how to set their prevailing wages.
What comes next
These changes are proposed, not final. The current PERM regulations continue to govern until DOL issues a final rule and that rule takes effect, and the proposal does not affect how pending applications or applications filed today are adjudicated.
The public may submit comments through January 19, 2027, at regulations.gov (Docket No. ETA-2026-0133). DOL must consider those comments before finalizing the rule, and the final version may differ, possibly substantially, from the proposal.
As drafted, a final rule would take effect 60 calendar days after publication, followed by a transition period: PERM applications and prevailing wage requests filed within 29 days after the effective date would be reviewed under the current rules, and those filed on or after the 30th day would be subject to the new rules. Legal challenges to a final rule could further affect timing.
For more information, please contact me or your regular Parker Poe attorney. Click here to subscribe to our latest alerts and insights.