In less than three weeks, California’s two privacy enforcers announced resolutions of four cases built on the same allegation: A consumer’s choice to opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information did not take effect as promised. The California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) fined FedEx $2.975 million, Hertz $1.55 million, and Filson $217,987 in decisions dated November 6, 2026, and California Attorney General Rob Bonta announced a $1.8 million settlement with Lyft on October 29, 2026.
This uptick in enforcement orders spells out how a business is expected to test its websites and apps, and CalPrivacy’s board has advanced amendments that would write the same expectations into its regulations. The number of opt-out signals is also about to grow, because California’s Opt Me Out Act requires web browsers to offer one beginning in January 2027. Any business subject to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) that runs advertising tags on a site or app that Californians use, including a business-to-business site, should measure its controls against those terms.
Background
The CCPA gives consumers the right to direct a business not to sell or share their personal information, and a business that receives that direction must stop. Under the act, sharing means disclosing personal information to a third party for cross-context behavioral advertising or "targeted" advertising, which is what most third-party advertising pixels and cookies do. A business that sells or shares personal information must treat a browser-based opt-out preference signal such as global privacy control (GPC) as a valid opt-out for that browser or device and any consumer profile tied to it. The regulations do not yet name GPC, but the FedEx, Hertz, and Filson orders each say the duty to honor such signals dates to 2020.
CalPrivacy alleged that FedEx’s privacy policy said the company did not sell or share personal information while advertising trackers ran on its sites, that FedEx ignored GPCs, and that its request form and cookie controls did not stop the tracking. Hertz allegedly did not honor GPCs on its Hertz, Dollar, and Thrifty websites, and a cookie settings window on two of those sites reset to allow advertising cookies when closed without saving. Filson allegedly had no opt-out link, offered request channels that did not work, and ignored GPCs. The attorney general alleged that Lyft offered no opt-out inside its app and sent signed-in users to a web page that required a new login and identity verification. None of the companies admitted liability, and the court entered the stipulated Lyft judgment on October 30, 2026.
Analysis
The legal theory is familiar. What stands out is the operating detail in the remedies dictated by the state regulators. FedEx and Hertz must inventory their tracking technologies every quarter, review each new tracker before it goes live, and test quarterly, in both staging and production environments, whether an opt-out stops the data flow. Hertz must also check for a GPC signal before loading any tracker that sells or shares data, and its testing must cover every tag management container, multiple browsers and mobile platforms, server-side and client-side trackers, and both known and unknown visitors. Hertz also may not rely solely on a consent management platform’s or other vendor’s word and must assess those vendors independently at least twice a year. The obligations run for three years.
The FedEx order applies these rules in a business-to-business setting, noting that people use the same devices for work and personal activity. CalPrivacy was prepared to seek a multimillion-dollar fine from Filson and accepted $217,987 only after reviewing confidential financial records showing that the company could not pay more. The order also requires the company to stop selling and sharing Californians' data with advertising technology companies within 30 days unless an officer or director certifies under penalty of perjury that it is meeting the order’s audit, testing, and training terms. Filson’s order counts each disclosure to each advertising company, on each visit by an opted-out consumer, as its own violation, a method that multiplies exposure quickly.
On November 6, 2026, CalPrivacy’s board voted 5-0 to authorize formal rulemaking on amendments that would write part of this into the regulations. The draft would add GPC by name as an example of a qualifying signal, add an example stating that a business must check for a signal before setting cookies or loading trackers that enable sale or sharing, and direct many more businesses to publish annual request metrics, including opt-outs received by signal. CalPrivacy describes the first two changes as clarifications of existing law, and the Hertz order already applies the timing rule under the current regulations, so businesses should not wait for a final rule.
Practical implications for businesses
The Hertz order provides the most detailed checklist businesses should consider:
- Inventory: Scan every website and app at least quarterly and keep a current list of every tracker that sells or shares personal information.
- Timing: Check for a GPC signal before loading any of those trackers.
- Testing: Test at least quarterly, in both staging and production, and again whenever a new tracker is added.
- Review: Examine network activity, whether trackers execute, what gets written to storage, and how the system behaves before and after an opt-out.
- What to cover: Every website and app, tag management container, browsers and mobile platform, server-side and client-side tracker, and known and unknown visitors.
- Scenarios: Compare a signal opt-out with a cookie-banner opt-out; and test a first-time visitor with no consent state and a visitor who changes preferences.
- Request channels: Test the methods for submitting CCPA requests at least quarterly.
- Vendors: Assess at least twice a year whether the consent platform and other providers are doing what they claim.
- New third parties: Confirm the contract and the opt-out configuration are in place before the technology runs.
- Opt-out methods: Offer an opt-out inside any app, do not make signed-in users log in again to use it, and do not send consumers to industry opt-out pages in place of your own methods.
For more information, please contact us or your regular Parker Poe contact. Click here to subscribe to our latest alerts and insights.